Published and NSManaged

July 13, 2020 • 11:31 PM

While developing a universal app with the updated SwiftUI framework, I found that @Published decorators do not function as intended in objects inheriting from NSManagedObject class.

What’s Expected & What’s Broken

What’s exactly the expected behaviour anyway? We know that —

  • Objects conforming to ObservableObject protocol can have variables marked with @Published. SwiftUI views that depends on an observable object instance will update when a published variable receives a new value.
  • Objects inheriting from NSManagedObject class can have variables marked with @NSManaged. SwiftUI views that depends on an NSManagedObject will update when the @NSManaged variable receives a new value in the managed context.
  • ObservableObject is RAM only; NAManagedObject is written to the Core Data context and optionally saved to disk.
  • Objects inheriting from NSManagedObject class automatically conforms to ObservableObject. So they should be able to mark variables with either @Published or @NSManaged to have views updated automatically. You will want to use @Published to update variables that update frequently but needs no disk persistence.

But here’s what is broken: Published variables in NSManagedObject instances do not update SwiftUI views as expected.

The Cause

As discussed on Stack Overflow, this is likely a bug on Apple’s end. There have been discussions since September 2019 but this problem still exists today. Somehow the implementation of ObservableObject protocol for NSManagedObject doesn’t trigger objectWillChange.send() method.

The Workaround

Since the objectWillChange.send() method doesn’t get triggered, the workaround is to simply trigger it manually.

Consult to Jesse Spencer’s answer in the same thread. Or the answer of Anthony’s.

Let’s stay in touch!

Sign up for the weekly updates of anything that appears on this blog. You will read about my outdoor life around British Columbia, technical discussions as a Data Analyst & App Developer, as well as other random discoveries and thoughts.

Blog Posts Archive